Six years apart, and one old will
Elaine and Gary separated six years ago. There was no big blowup at the end, just a long stretch of two people growing apart and wanting different things. Gary stayed in the house. Elaine bought a condo across town. They split the furniture, opened their own bank accounts, and agreed they’d deal with the divorce once things settled down.
Things did settle down. Elaine met Dennis, and four years ago he moved into the condo with her. Her adult children, Kristen and Josh, like him. The four of them spend Christmas together. As far as Elaine is concerned, her marriage to Gary ended a long time ago.
Her will doesn’t see it that way. She signed it in 2014, when she and Gary were still together. It leaves everything to Gary and names him as her Executor. Kristen and Josh only inherit if Gary dies first. Dennis isn’t in it at all, because Elaine hadn’t met him yet.
If Elaine died tomorrow, Gary could be the one settling her estate. Depending on where she lives, he’d be dealing with her bank, deciding what happens to her condo, and telling Dennis how long he can stay in the home they’ve shared for four years. Dennis would have no say in any of it.
Separated isn’t the same as divorced
When you separate, you stop living as a couple. In law, you’re still married until a court grants a divorce. Most people know that. What they often don’t think about is that their will, their beneficiary forms and their power of attorney may still be set up for the marriage they’ve left behind.
A will doesn’t update itself when your life changes. It says what it said the day you signed it. If it leaves everything to “my husband, Gary,” it means Gary, whether you lived with him last week or haven’t spoken to him in five years.
In a few parts of Canada, the law now steps in after a separation. Where it does, a spouse you’ve lived apart from for a set period because the marriage broke down, or one you’ve signed a separation agreement with, can be treated as though they died before you. Your gifts to them fall away, and so does their appointment as Executor. How long you need to be apart, and what counts, isn’t the same from one jurisdiction to the next.
In many other places, separation on its own doesn’t change your will at all. Even a divorce doesn’t tidy up everything everywhere. A divorce cancels gifts to a former spouse and removes them as Executor in many jurisdictions, but not in all of them, and those rules usually don’t reach anything outside your will. If you’re already partway through a divorce, I wrote about what to update while it’s still in progress.
Who’s affected when the will is out of date
An outdated will doesn’t hurt the person who wrote it. It hurts the people left behind, and after a long separation that’s usually three of them.
Your current partner. Dennis has shared a home with Elaine for four years, and under her will he receives nothing. Depending on where they live, he may be able to make a claim against her estate, but that means hiring a lawyer and going to court while he’s still grieving, against her family and possibly against Gary.
Your former spouse. Gary may not want to be a part of any of this. But if the will names him, he’s the beneficiary, and if he’s the Executor, he’s the one dealing with Dennis and the kids. Some people in Gary’s position do the decent thing and some don’t. Your plan shouldn’t depend on which kind of person your ex turns out to be.
Your adult children. Kristen and Josh probably assume their mom’s estate will come to them, or at least be shared with Dennis. Under the 2014 will, they only inherit if their dad dies first. If Gary inherits and later remarries, or leaves his own estate to someone else, what their mother intended for them may never reach them. I’ve written before about what can happen when a parent counts on someone else to look after their children’s inheritance, in Why a Basic Will Isn’t Enough for Blended Families.
When the Executor is the spouse he left
Murray and Joyce separated eleven years before he died. They’d both moved on, but neither of them ever filed for divorce. Where they lived, the separation didn’t change Murray’s will, which named Joyce as his Executor and left her everything.
Patty, his partner of eight years, learned after the funeral that she had no say in anything. Joyce had his bank statements, the keys to his truck and the final word on everything in his name, including the holiday trailer he and Patty had picked out together. Patty’s only option was to hire a lawyer and make a claim against the estate.
What else still has your spouse’s name on it
Your will isn’t the only place to look. RRSPs, RRIFs, TFSAs, life insurance and some pensions let you name a beneficiary directly, and that designation generally overrides your will. Whoever you named stays the beneficiary until the designation is changed. Separating doesn’t change it, and neither does writing a new will that leaves everything to someone else. Some designations can’t be changed on your own, either. An irrevocable designation needs the beneficiary’s consent, and in Quebec, naming a married spouse as beneficiary on a life insurance policy is irrevocable unless the policy says otherwise. Your separation agreement may also require you to keep your spouse as a beneficiary.
Pensions also have their own rules about who counts as a spouse when you die, and those rules don’t always align with your current circumstances. It’s worth asking your plan administrator what happens to your pension if you die while you’re still legally married to someone you no longer live with.
The will was new, the insurance form wasn’t
Magdalena and Phil separated, and three years later Magdalena did what she’d been putting off. She made a new will leaving her estate to her two sons.
She didn’t think about the group life insurance she’d signed up for at work fifteen years earlier, which still named Phil as beneficiary. When she died, the insurance company paid Phil directly. Her new will had no say over that money, and her sons received less than half of what she’d intended them to have.
If you recognize yourself in Elaine’s story, the answer is a will that reflects the life you’re living now: the people in it, what you own, and who you trust to look after it. The Will Blueprint™ guides you through preparing your will with context for where you live, including the beneficiary designation decisions that sit outside your will.
Your Power of Attorney may need a look too
Your will only matters after you die. Your power of attorney and health care directive look after you, if a stroke, a fall or an illness leaves you unable to manage your own affairs or speak for yourself. That can happen at any age, and it can go on for years.
If you named your spouse as your Power of Attorney or as the person to make your medical decisions, picture what happens if you have a stroke next month. Gary could be the one managing Elaine’s money and talking to her doctors, while Dennis, the person who’s actually by her side, has no legal say. Depending on where you live, a separation or divorce may or may not end those appointments. Don’t assume it has. Read the documents, and if they no longer name the people you’d trust, have them replaced.
What changes depending on where you live
The rules on separation, divorce and wills aren’t the same across Canada, and in Quebec they come from its civil law system. Some places have changed their rules in recent years, so what a friend was told in another province, or what was true when you separated, may not apply to you now.
Updating your will also doesn’t settle what your spouse may be entitled to under family property law. That’s a separate question, and if your separation was never finalized, it may still be open.
Because so much depends on where you live, the best next step is a conversation with a lawyer, or a notary in Quebec, before you sign anything new.
The paperwork you meant to get to
Elaine could fix most of this without finalizing the divorce. A new will, updated beneficiary forms, a new power of attorney and a health care directive would make sure Dennis, Kristen and Josh are looked after the way she intends, and would leave Gary out of decisions he probably never wanted to make.
If your will still describes a life you left years ago, it’s been waiting for you to get around to it. It doesn’t have to wait any longer.
Visit our services page to see how we can help.
Watch our video here, or watch on our YouTube Channel:
Prefer a podcast? Listen here!
Please send us your questions or share your comments.
Disclaimer: This content is for general information only and is not legal, financial, medical, or tax advice.
