Of Course She’d Do It

When Harold asked his daughter Lisa to be his Executor, they were sitting at his kitchen table with his new will between them. He’d just come back from the lawyer’s office. Lisa didn’t let him finish asking the question. Of course she’d do it. He was her dad.

Harold died four years later. Within a month, Lisa was returning calls from his bank on her lunch break, because that was the only time she could reach anyone. She didn’t know filing his final tax return was her job until his accountant asked whether she’d started on it. Her brother Greg called every few weeks to ask why nothing had been paid out yet, and most of those calls ended with one of them hanging up. She used nearly all of her vacation days that year on appointments, and she hadn’t really had time to grieve.

It took eighteen months to close the estate. When it was finally done, Lisa said she’d do it again for her dad. But she also said she wished someone had told her what she was agreeing to at that kitchen table.


Lisa’s Story Is the Common One

A national survey released earlier this month puts numbers to what I see in my work all the time. It was commissioned by ClearEstate Technologies and conducted by Canada Pulse Insights, who asked more than 3,000 Canadian adults about naming an Executor and serving as one.

Among people with a completed estate plan who haven’t named a professional Executor, 82% have named a family member or friend. More than half of them, 58%, said they chose the most trustworthy person they know, not the most qualified person or the one with the most time. And three out of four Canadians said they’d accept the role for a family member or close friend even without fully understanding what it involves.

Lisa shows up in those numbers twice. Her dad chose her because he trusted her, and she said yes before she knew what the job was.

People seem to know it’s a lot to ask. About 63% agreed it’s unfair to expect a family member to manage all the administrative, legal and financial work of settling an estate without support. Among the one in five Canadians who’ve already served as an Executor, the median time spent was 35 hours, and 39% put in 50 hours or more. ClearEstate says even estates with no disputes usually take 12 to 18 months to settle.

Other estimates run much higher. An executor software company, EstateExec, found its users spent an average of about 570 hours settling an estate, and in a recent Canadian Press article, Willful co-founder Erin Bury put it at “hundreds of hours of work.”

Those hours get spread over a year or more, in phone calls that have to happen during the workday, forms that often need an original signature, and offices that close before you’re off work.

A Few Weekends, He Thought

When Colin agreed to be Executor for his aunt Bev, he figured it would take a few weekends. Two months after Bev died, her house sold, and Colin thought he was nearly done. Then came filing her final tax return, and after that, months of waiting for confirmation from the tax authorities that everything had been paid, before he could safely distribute anything. Her nieces and nephews kept asking why the money was still sitting there. It was more than two years before Colin wrote the last cheque.


Two Separate Questions

When people talk about choosing an Executor, they usually treat it as one decision. I think it’s really two.

The first is who you name. Trust matters here, and naming someone who loves you to look after your affairs isn’t a mistake. When the survey asked people who they’d name today, about half chose a family member or close friend who could bring in professionals as needed. Only 22% would choose a fully professional arrangement, through a specialist service or a financial institution or trust company.

I understand the intention behind that choice. Most families don’t want a stranger settling a parent’s estate. A family Executor can bring in a lawyer, an accountant or a Certified Executor Advisor to help, and the cost of that help is generally paid by the estate. What they can’t hand off is the responsibility. The Executor still makes the decisions, still answers to the beneficiaries, and can still be held personally liable if something goes wrong. I’ve written before about what a court expects of an Executor, and it’s a higher standard than most people realize when they agree to the role.

The second question is what that person needs so they can walk in prepared, and hardly anyone asks it. Lisa had her dad’s trust, and his will was in order. What she didn’t have was any sense of what the next eighteen months would look like, what had to be done first, or where her dad kept everything. She’s not alone in that either. Nearly half of the people in the survey who’ve named a family Executor weren’t sure how that person would find their accounts, deeds and passwords.

I’ve acted as an Executor, a Power of Attorney and a Medical Representative more than once, and those experiences are a big part of why I became a Certified Executor Advisor.

If you’ve been asked to be someone’s Executor, or you’ve already said yes, a little preparation now can change what the job feels like later. These tools were built for that:

  • Before You Say Yes™ is for anyone who’s been asked to act as Executor and wants to think it through privately before answering.
  • The Executor’s Standard™ uses realistic scenarios to show the standard an Executor is held to, and where personal liability usually begins.
  • Executor’s Compass™ Suite brings practical guidance together with working tools, including the Estate Administration Timeline and the Estate Administration Spreadsheet, so you can track the estate as you go.

If You’re the One Doing the Asking

Asking someone you trust is a good start. You can also make their job much easier while you’re still here to help.

Have the conversation properly, not as a quick comment or question at the end of a phone call or a visit. Tell them what the role involves and give them the right to say no. Show them where your will is kept and who your lawyer or notary is. Make sure they know where to find your accounts, insurance policies and passwords. And tell the rest of your family who you’ve named, so your Executor isn’t the one breaking that news.

An Afternoon That Saved Months

When Pauline’s mother named her Executor, she set aside an afternoon to go over everything. She showed Pauline the binder with her accounts and policies, called her lawyer so the two of them could be introduced, and told Pauline’s two sisters who she’d named and why. After her mother died, the estate still took well over a year to settle. But Pauline didn’t spend any of it searching for accounts or defending herself to her sisters.

It’s also worth asking whether the person you’re naming as Executor is the same person you’ve named as your Power of Attorney. Many people choose the same person for both. Your Executor only steps in after you die. Your Power of Attorney could be needed while you’re still alive, after a stroke, a fall or a dementia diagnosis. Whether you’ve chosen the same person for both roles or two different people, they deserve the same honest conversation before they agree.


What Changes Depending on Where You Live

The basics of the role are much the same across Canada, but the details vary. Even the title changes. In Quebec, for example, the Executor is called a liquidator. Whether the estate needs probate, how you apply, what it costs, and the rules around notifying creditors all depend on the province or territory. Federal tax filings go to the Canada Revenue Agency everywhere, and in Quebec there are provincial filings with Revenu Québec as well.

That’s why it matters to understand the role where you live before you say yes, or before you ask someone else to. The Executor tools I mentioned earlier are built around your province or territory, and a lawyer, or a notary in Quebec, can tell you what applies to your situation.


Closing Thoughts

Lisa doesn’t regret saying yes. She does wonder how differently those eighteen months might have gone if she and her dad had spent one more hour at that kitchen table talking about what the job would really involve.

If someone has asked you, or you’re about to ask someone, that hour is worth having now.


Visit our services page to see how we can help.

Watch our video here, or watch on our YouTube Channel:

Prefer a podcast? Listen here!

Please send us your questions or share your comments.

Disclaimer: This content is for general information only and is not legal, financial, medical, or tax advice.